IC-1244GPT-4's non-zero scores on GAIA web browsing questions are largely due to memorization of intermediate information from training data rather than actual web browsing

Report a problem with this record

Grégoire Mialon, Clémentine Fourrier, Thomas Wolf, Yann LeCun, Thomas Scialom

SourceGAIA: a benchmark for General AI Assistants

When evaluating GPT-4 without tools on GAIA level 1 questions, the model achieves non-zero scores on questions that annotators solved via web browsing. The paper attributes these scores primarily to GPT-4 having memorized pieces of information needed to complete intermediate steps, rather than to any actual browsing capability. This means the model's apparent web browsing performance is a shortcut that would fail for questions requiring information not present in its training data. The paper notes that GPT-4 cannot deal with files and multi-modality at all, further confirming its limitations in tool use.

Evidence
correlational
Caveat
The paper does not provide a precise count of how many web browsing questions were answered via memorization versus other means; the attribution is qualitative ('mostly due to correct memorization').
Model
GPT-4 / ChatGPT4 / GPT-4 Code Interpreter / GPT-4 Technical Report
Concepts
Shortcut
Datasets
GAIA [eval]
Related findings
IC-1243
Extraction
automatic-extraction